779 reviews · 776 verified
96% would recommend
5 ★
654
4 ★
85
3 ★
16
2 ★
10
1 ★
14

Reviews

What customers said

Page 38 of 78
Service date  2018-05-15
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Oil change

Good

Gloria & Randy V. · Menasha, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-05-14
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Powder Coated Rims

Fast professional service. Had one sales person handle my needs start to finish. Like that. Completed tire & rim swap out, eveything was as they promised it would be.

Gregg J. · New London, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-05-10
Verified Service Visit

Average

Tires were not available on day scheduled to be installed. Had to wait extra day. Service person did not seem surprised that this happened. Led me to believe this was not unusual. Reason for not referring.

Tim & Deb M. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-05-11
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Great people and wonderful service

Kurt H. · Neenah, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-05-09
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

service

I set up an appt. for LOF and I had a slight wobble in the steering. They found a belt had shifted on a front tire. I decided to change all four tires, the alignment was off and was corrected. The staff made sure I understood what was wrong and what costs were involved. Thanks for great service.

Bob B. · Neenah, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-05-09
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

People taking care of people!

Creg, Jason, Monica & Sean along with a fantastic group of mechanics have always provided the best service I could ever ask for! Im very happy to have our vehicles service exclusively at Mathews tire and auto! Your the best!

Dan Sr & Cindy S. · Pine River, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-05-03
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Tire installation

Good job and good customer service! Got me in on short notice

Karen K. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-04-27
Posted on the website
Would recommend

Alignment

Brought my sister in laws pt cruiser in to get an alignment had great customer service and everything they called me to let me know the front camber was off... they told me the extra cost if they fixed but most of all they asked me if I wanted them to fix the front camber instead of fixing it and throwing on the bill

Jerome R. · Menasha, WI
Service date  2018-04-28
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Tire swap & head lights

Visited Matthews Menasha for my spring tire swap yesterday and was in an out in an hour. One of the reasons I like Matthews is they store my tires in the office season. I noticed the night before that one of my headlights was out so I asked if the could handle replacing both...no problem but before we do it let me call you with a price because replacing some types of head lights in a Camry can take hours. Fortunate for me I had the typical type.Matthew's great service, great customer service and their not just about tires.

Wayne C. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-04-26
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

replacement tire

After buying 4 new tires in November, I discovered a small bulge in a rear tire. Stopped in and showed to Jason. He checked and could get a tire in a couple of hours and offered me a loaner vehicle to use to get back to work for the afternoon. Picked up my vehicle after work (new tire installed)! Couldn't have been given better service:)

Louise Z. · Menasha, WI · Verified customer

Also on Google

Google reviews

See this shop's Google rating and a few of its Google reviews, shown separately from the reviews above.