Appleton, WI

Matthews Tire

1,406 reviews · 1,397 verified
98% would recommend
5 ★
1,243
4 ★
112
3 ★
23
2 ★
18
1 ★
10

Reviews

What customers said

Page 120 of 141
Service date  2016-09-13
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Brakes and Oil Change

Bergstrom said I needed brakes and rotors. because of the cost I was quoted I checked with Mathews. They told me I did not need Rotors on the back and also quoted a cheaper price. the service was top notch and the estimate was exactly what I was told.

Reggie D. · Neenah, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2016-09-12
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

HELP BEYOND THE NORM

even when they had no chance to make the sale Jason still went out of his way to make sure that we got our car back on the road with as few a problems as possible. THANK YOU JASON!

Charlotte S. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2016-08-30
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Exceptional Service

I brought in a tire for a leaking valve core R&R and wound up with a bubble in the tire sidewall after reinstallation. The tire was deemed defective and was adjusted by prorated formula for new replacement. I felt that was a very fair solution to a bad situation as there was only maybe 15,000 miles on this 4 year old tire. Yes, I was not happy with having to buy a new tire but, the professionals at Mathews at least took way some of the pain away with a very fair and equitable solution! This is why I will continue to go back to Mathews for all my family tire needs.Thanks Again!Five Star Service

Carl W R. · Hortonville, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2016-09-09
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Great Service

I had an excellent experience again. I came for an oil change and was alerted to the fact that my fuel and oil system could use a cleaning. Very courteous and helpful tech. No pushing of services, just the facts.

Robert F. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2016-09-08
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Tire Pressure

I had a very good appointment and everything went really well yesterday. But today my tire pressure light went on again?!?

Kerri A. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2016-09-08
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Jan Stertz

Thank you for the wonderful service and product I received at your College Ave Company. Tyler was extremely helpful and informative.

Jan S. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2016-09-07
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Wascher Greg

Great honest professional every time :-)

Greg W. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2016-09-06
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Excellent

Always treated well by a friendly staff and knowledgeable mechanics.

Jack R. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2016-09-03
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

oil change

great service as always

Ken A. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2016-09-02
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Review title

positive experience I don't have time to fill this out

Tom & Patricia K. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer

Also on Google

Google reviews

See this shop's Google rating and a few of its Google reviews, shown separately from the reviews above.